A few years ago in 2019, the fire that seriously damaged Notre Dame Cathedral in Paris was quite shocking. Many people expressed profound grief and sadness over the damage to this 850-year-old religious icon and sacred space. People watched in total disbelief as the roof and famous spire crumpled to the ground. This invaluable piece of history was gone in an instant, but the loss inspired many people gathered in the streets to sing hymns and offer prayers to God. Their reaction highlights perhaps in a unique way a point about sacred spaces that scripture makes plain. Sacred spaces are fundamentally more than designated physical locations. A sacred space is first and foremost a matter of the heart.
The story in the Book of Exodus about Moses encountering the burning bush on Mt. Horeb is a good illustration of this point. Moses approaches the bush out of curiosity, but God stops him and says, “Do not come near! Remove your sandals from your feet, for the place where you stand is holy ground” (Ex 3:3-6). Only after Moses complies does God identify himself and reveal his intentions.
This story shows that any space where we encounter God is sacred by virtue of God’s very presence. Asking Moses to remove his sandals as a sign of respect is a further indication that a genuine encounter with God calls for a right heart, one in sync with the values of God (1 Sam 16:7). “Rend your hearts, not your garments,” in other words (Jl 2:13). This fundamental need for a right heart as an essential aspect of encountering God is exactly how Isaiah begins his discussion of God’s “house of prayer” in the first reading for today.
Isaiah begins by calling attention to the fundamental role of a right heart as the spiritual cornerstone in God’s house of prayer. He makes this point with the opening line when he says on behalf of the Lord, “Observe what is right, do what is just” (Is 56:1). We express this focus at the beginning of each Eucharistic prayer. It is “right and just” that we encounter God with gratitude and the right spiritual focus on his values.
Isaiah provides more detail about what this means when he says that, “All foreigners (that is, not just the Israelites) who join themselves to the Lord (in other words, all those with the right spiritual focus) who “keep the sabbath free from profanation and hold to my covenant, them I will bring to my holy mountain and make joyful in my house of prayer…for my house shall be called a house of prayer for all peoples” (Is 56:1). Jesus puts it more simply when he says “where two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them” (Mt 18:20).
The prophet Jeremiah reiterates the same need for a right heart when he warns the Israelites to reform their ways so that God may dwell with them where they are (Jer 7:2-3). Jeremiah points the way when he describes a right heart as one that is humble, always treats others with justice, protects the freedom and dignity of aliens, shows genuine care and concern for vulnerable persons, especially widows and orphans, and refuses to be deceived by false gods (Jer 7:3-6). These are the values of God meant to guide our lives. Deliberately adopting these values demonstrates our genuine love and respect for God, and allows for the genuine love of others.
Jesus reaffirms this way of life when he says to the Samaritan woman at the well, “Believe me, woman, the hour is coming when you will worship the Father neither on this mountain nor in Jerusalem…the hour is coming, and is now here, when true worshipers will worship the Father in Spirit and truth; and indeed, the Father seeks such people to worship him. God is Spirit, and those who worship him must worship in Spirit and truth” (Jn 4:21-23). Jesus makes this claim based on the premise that God’s house of prayer is more than a dedicated physical space. A heart formed by faith and trust in God is the basis of a true house of prayer.
The idea of placing our faith and trust in God as the first step in authentic worship is the whole point of the gospel story about the Canaanite woman. She comes to Jesus out of desperation and begs him to heal her daughter. Undeterred by the disciples who want Jesus to send her away, the woman comes to Jesus with a humble heart filled with faith and trust. Jesus eventually does what the woman requests, but not before he puts her faith to the test with a dilemma to resolve.
Jesus begins the dilemma with the claim that his mission is only to the lost sheep of Israel. His initial response implies to the woman that, because she is a foreigner, a Canaanite and not an Israelite, she is therefore outside his mission. She hears and understands his issue, but persists in her plea for help, only to have Jesus further characterize fulfilling her request in terms of throwing the bread of children to dogs. But, Jesus does not send her away, nor does he say that he will not do as she asks. Rather, he simply characterizes the nature of his possible assistance, and then he waits. He waits to see how she will respond, because how she responds will be the measure of her faith and trust in God.
The woman responds without hesitation and says that even dogs eat scraps from the table. With this comment, she boldly suggests that fulfilling her request would require no more of Jesus than giving her scraps from the spiritual feast meant for the Israelites. Her comment virtually overwhelms Jesus, which he acknowledges with deep emotion: “O woman, great is your faith! Let it be done for you as you wish.” Jesus embraces the way she unravels the dilemma because she comes to him with humility, faith, and trust. She comes with the right spiritual focus to make herself a part of his mission. In this way, she reveals what a house of prayer truly is—encountering God with a right heart born of faith and trust.
In this interaction with the Canaanite woman, Jesus provides a deeper understanding not only of God’s love and mercy, but also a better understanding of what it means to encounter God with a right heart. Jesus aims to show that God’s house of prayer is not exclusive to one group or another. Rather, God’s house of prayer is sacred space open and available to all those who place their faith and trust in Him (1Pt 5:7).
The inevitable conclusion to all of this is that sacred space is more than a designated physical space. Sacred space is fundamentally a mutual experience between God and a person with a right heart formed by faith and trust in Him. A right heart remains in sync with the values of God out of respect for his presence in ourselves and in others. These are the necessary conditions for authentic worship of God in Spirit and truth. Therefore, encountering God on these terms in any space constitutes a genuine “house of prayer.”