This coming Tuesday we will celebrate Mardi Gras in preparation for Lent. A fun part of Mardi Gras is the enjoyment of many foods and various delights before giving up some of them for Lent. Another fun part of this celebration are the many parades and costume parties that go on. Putting on a costume and mask to hide our true identity is always fun because we can pretend to be anybody we want. Indeed, pretense is the whole point of wearing a mask.
In real life, we also wear masks for the same reason. At times, we want to pretend in a way that conceals our thoughts or emotions, or enables us to meet social expectations, or to hide our true intentions. In most cases, the pretense is a harmless part of ordinary living, like putting your best foot forward, so to speak. The innocence of wearing a mask disappears, however, when the pretense becomes an excuse for mistreating or unjustly harming others.
The injustice of this kind of pretense is precisely why Jesus called out the hypocritical behavior of the Pharisees. Their public pretense of keeping the Word of God concealed their fake piety and religious elitism. Their mask enabled the extortion and mistreatment of others for personal gain. They had taken the wrong road. Theirs was an inauthentic faith that undercut their true spiritual destiny by steering them away from the true God. Jesus wants us to go the other way and stay on the right road of authentic faith based on the values and wisdom of God.
To that end, he does something a bit unexpected. He provides several examples to help us think outside the box and expose the illusion and spiritual danger of an inauthentic faith. He deepens our understanding in that regard by describing anger as having the same root as murder. He warns us to settle our differences before offering our gifts at the altar. He claims that the vows of marriage require more than a pretense of loyalty. He says that mocking others and calling them names is a form of cruelty subject to severe judgement.
From a modern perspective, these claims appear absurd, impractical, and unreasonable. Today, we readily shun those who hate us. We think nothing of returning insult for insult. We imprison those who steal as common criminals, and we expect repayment in full for money loaned. We only give to those who deserve it, and we know exactly who qualifies. We view bad behavior as deserving of just punishment.
Authentic faith, on the other hand, calls for a different perspective—love of enemies, doing good to those who hate us, giving more to the one who steals from us, lending without expecting a return, refusing to judge and condemn others. Jesus wants us to stop focusing on who deserves our help, and instead, offer assistance when and where needed regardless of why the person needs our help. This is not to say that motive counts for nothing, but it does mean that we cannot turn our backs on those who need our cloak, our funds, our respect. To refuse such help is unjust.
God gives us a choice between life and death, good and evil. Whichever we choose will be given us. We receive back what we give: give and gifts will be given in good measure…overflowing in fact (Ps 126:5; Lk 6:38). We can live by the wisdom and values of God if we so choose (Sir 15:15). As Jesus puts it, whoever wishes to save his life will lose it, and whoever loses his life for my sake, will find it (Mt 16:25). The inference of that choice is plain enough—we literally build our spiritual life both here and in the hereafter by the way we live day by day, deed by deed, choice by choice.
We simply make better choices on our spiritual journey when we love others in a way that is shaped by our love for God. This is the point that Christ makes when he emphasizes the preeminence of love with the two great commandments. For Jesus, love binds us to each other and to God in a dynamic, interconnected relationship. The result is that whatever we do to and for the other, we do to and for Christ himself. Living by the principle of love means that we see things in a different way than is expected. We see with the eyes of the soul rather than with ordinary eyes.
With ordinary eyes, many of the “least” don’t look as we imagine God. The least may frighten us, be different from us, or seem undeserving. Such a vision leads us to give only to those who give to us; to do good to those who do good to us; lend only to those who will repay. Jesus calls us to a different way of life, a different way of seeing things. Jesus expects us to live according to the values and wisdom of God.
In essence, Jesus expects us to follow him on his path of love. He is our model for daily living in both word and deed. We put on the mind of Christ without pretense to see ourselves and others as Jesus sees us—with the eyes of love. This is the essence of authentic faith that enables us to be the kind of person we are meant to be, in which case we have no need of masks. This deeper perspective on authentic faith is what Jesus means when he says that he came not to abolish the law or the prophets, but to fulfill.