Saturday, May 24, 2014

Faith as Trust and Reason


A 5 Easter 14 (Jn 14:1-12)

            In a conversation about faith that Jesus has with his disciples, Jesus talks about faith in terms of both trust and reason.  Jesus makes the point that trust and reason both function as grounds for having faith in him. To demonstrate this point, Jesus first focuses on faith as a matter of trust. 
            Jesus begins with a twofold appeal to the disciples: “Do not let your hearts be troubled. You have faith in God; have faith also in me.”  In appealing first to the hearts of the disciples, Jesus shows that faith is primarily a matter of trust, that is, a matter for the heart rather than the head.  We can take to heart the word of Jesus.  We can rely on him, we can trust him, and therefore, we can have faith in him.
            Jesus does not ask for trust on false pretenses.  For, he makes it clear that he has no intention of abandoning his followers and leaving them to their own devices.  Rather, he goes ahead of them to prepare a place for them, and they know how to follow him.  Such consequences show the disciples that Jesus has their best interests at heart.  This is the nature of trust. 
            We trust someone because our hearts tell us that he or she has our backs.  Whether we have evidence for such trust may not matter all that much.  What seems to matter most is that we are confident that the person knows us, knows what is important to us, and will always act in ways that serve and protect our interests.  The critical aspect of trust is therefore confidence in the person we trust.  Thus, the initial appeal that Jesus makes to his disciples puts faith in him on par with trust in him, and trust is primarily a matter of the heart.
            By explaining faith first in terms of trust, Jesus in effect appeals to an ancient understanding of faith in God.  For the ancient Hebrews, faith in God was a two way street.  God wanted and eagerly sought out a relationship with his people.  They responded and entered that relationship by placing their trust in God.  Faith in God for the ancient Hebrews was an active relationship with God built on a lively belief and trust that He would make good on his promises; that God would indeed do as he said he would.  For this reason, their lives centered on their faith, and their faith shaped the way they lived.  For the ancient Hebrews, faith was a matter of trusting God.        
            But, the disciples Thomas and Phillip are less than convinced. They apparently need more than trust alone as the basis of their faith.  Thomas is the first to express such reservation by admitting no knowledge of where Jesus is going or how to get there. Philip displays a similar need for proof in asking to see the Father as reason enough for faith in Jesus.  These two disciples do not mistrust Jesus.  They simply express a very human need for having good reason when it comes to trust.  And, rather than taking offense, Jesus obliges.  He gives the disciples good reason for trusting him. 
            To show good reason for faith in him, Jesus relies on the second part of his twofold appeal: “You have faith in God; have faith also in me.”  This second part suggests a close union between Jesus and God, his father.  Jesus appeals to the close union between Father and Son as sufficient reason for having faith in him.  In other words, because of this close union, faith in God is the same thing as faith in Jesus.  We need no other proof.  This is the sense in which Jesus claims that faith in him is a matter of reason.
            But, Jesus goes a step further.  Jesus in effect says to the disciples, if you do not believe in me based on my word alone as a matter of trust, if you want proof, then, at least have faith in me because of the works that I do.  See what I have done out of love for you, for others, and for God.  Love proves itself in deeds.  These deeds are reason enough to have faith in Jesus.  Indeed, Jesus claims that “whoever believes in me, will do the works that I do, and will do greater ones than these, because I am going to the Father.”      
            Some of us may be able to trust with our hearts, and some of us are like Thomas and Philip, and trust with our reason.  Jesus understands this and acknowledges that there is more than one way to the Father.  The challenge for all of us, no matter how we arrive at our faith, is what to do with our faith.  In a sense, we are like the ancient Hebrews.  We too see faith as an active relationship with God, but we can be unsure of what that means. 
            The expected result is to live in imitation of Jesus.  His deeds grew out of his love for God and showed his love and care for others, all of whom he viewed as the beloved children of God.  For this reason, Jesus calls us to do the same by loving God with our whole hearts and minds and our neighbors as ourselves.  The encounter between Jesus and his disciples shows that our calling to love is primarily a matter of striving to do our best and trusting God.  Faith really demands no more.